
As the protoganist, Toru Okada, goes through suffering, the reader suffers with him. Him facing death at the bottom of a well, the stories about Lieutenant Mamiya’s wartime experiences were all emotionally very touching and heavy. At an intellectual level, I have great respect for its complexity, richness at different layers and strong themes.
My criticism is that at 600 pages, the book is too long and second half has unnecessary parts, making it feel fragmented and disconnected from the rest. It’s probably because the original Japanese edition was published in three parts, whereas the English translation omits certain chapters and combines it into a single book.
Overall, it’s a chaotic read, but one of the best novels I’ve read at the same time. Highly recommended!